TY - JOUR
T1 - Add Parsimony and Stir . . . Exploring the Explanation of State Crime
AU - Lynch, Michael
AU - Long, Michael
AU - Stretesky, Paul
PY - 2013/3
Y1 - 2013/3
N2 - In recent years there has been an attempt to develop a single, general theory of state crime. The procedure used for this purpose has involved ad hoc theorizing and thick descriptions based on qualitative data assessments from a relatively small number of cases. This creates a “theory” that describes all known information and is modified with the discovery of each new piece of information. Using this procedure, the theory proposes no hypotheses for testing, and cannot be falsified. Moreover, the theory is only based on “positive” cases or cases where state crimes are the given outcome (i.e., state crimes never fail to occur). The non-parsimonious nature of the theory that has resulted from these procedures cannot be empirically tested. For state crime theory to advance, parsimonious, empirically testable models with identifiable, measurable concepts must be pursued.
AB - In recent years there has been an attempt to develop a single, general theory of state crime. The procedure used for this purpose has involved ad hoc theorizing and thick descriptions based on qualitative data assessments from a relatively small number of cases. This creates a “theory” that describes all known information and is modified with the discovery of each new piece of information. Using this procedure, the theory proposes no hypotheses for testing, and cannot be falsified. Moreover, the theory is only based on “positive” cases or cases where state crimes are the given outcome (i.e., state crimes never fail to occur). The non-parsimonious nature of the theory that has resulted from these procedures cannot be empirically tested. For state crime theory to advance, parsimonious, empirically testable models with identifiable, measurable concepts must be pursued.
KW - State crime
KW - Parsimony in theory construction
KW - Ad hoc theory
KW - General theory
U2 - 10.1007/s12103-012-9157-3
DO - 10.1007/s12103-012-9157-3
M3 - Article
VL - 38
SP - 99
EP - 118
JO - American Journal of Criminal Justice
JF - American Journal of Criminal Justice
SN - 1066-2316
IS - 1
ER -