TY - JOUR
T1 - Correction to
T2 - Statistical Analysis of Solar Events Associated with Storm Sudden Commencements over One Year of Solar Maximum During Cycle 23: Propagation from the Sun to the Earth and Effects
AU - Bocchialini, K.
AU - Grison, B.
AU - Menvielle, M.
AU - Chambodut, A.
AU - Cornilleau-Wehrlin, N.
AU - Fontaine, D.
AU - Marchaudon, A.
AU - Pick, M.
AU - Pitout, F.
AU - Schmieder, B.
AU - Régnier, S.
AU - Zouganelis, I.
PY - 2019/4
Y1 - 2019/4
N2 - Taking the 32 storm sudden commencements (SSCs)
listed by the International Service of Geomagnetic Indices (ISGI) of the
Observatory de l’Ebre during 2002 (solar activity maximum in Cycle 23) as a
starting point, we performed a multi-criterion analysis based on observations
(propagation time, velocity comparisons, sense of the magnetic field rotation,
radio waves) to associate them with solar sources, identified their effects in
the interplanetary medium, and looked at the response of the terrestrial
ionized and neutral environment. We find that 28 SSCs can be related to 44
coronal mass ejections (CMEs), 15 with a unique CME and 13 with a series of
multiple CMEs, among which 19 (68%) involved halo CMEs. Twelve of the 19
fastest CMEs with speeds greater than 1000 km s−1 are halo CMEs. For the 44
CMEs, including 21 halo CMEs, the corresponding X-ray flare classes are: 4
X-class, 19 M-class, and 21 C-class flares. The probability for an SSC to occur
is 75% if the CME is a halo CME. Among the 500, or even more, front-side,
non-halo CMEs recorded in 2002, only 23 could be the source of an SSC, i.e. 5%.
The complex interactions between two (or more) CMEs and the modification of
their trajectories have been examined using joint white-light and
multiple-wavelength radio observations. The detection of long-lasting type IV
bursts observed at metric–hectometric wavelengths is a very useful criterion
for the CME–SSC association. The events associated with the most depressed Dst
values are also associated with type IV radio bursts. The four SSCs associated
with a single shock at L1 correspond to four radio events exhibiting
characteristics different from type IV radio bursts. The solar-wind structures
at L1 after the 32 SSCs are 12 magnetic clouds (MCs), 6 interplanetary coronal
mass ejections (ICMEs) without an MC structure, 4 miscellaneous structures,
which cannot unambiguously be classified as ICMEs, 5 corotating or stream
interaction regions (CIRs/SIRs), one CIR caused two SSCs, and 4 shock events;
note that one CIR caused two SSCs. The 11 MCs listed in 3 or more MC catalogs
covering the year 2002 are associated with SSCs. For the three most intense
geomagnetic storms (based on Dst minima) related to MCs, we note two sudden
increases of the Dst, at the arrival of the sheath and the arrival of the MC
itself. In terms of geoeffectiveness, the relation between the CME speed and
the magnetic-storm intensity, as characterized using the Dst magnetic index, is
very complex, but generally CMEs with velocities at the Sun larger than 1000
km s−1 have larger probabilities to trigger moderate or intense storms. The
most geoeffective events are MCs, since 92% of them trigger moderate or intense
storms, followed by ICMEs (33%). At best, CIRs/SIRs only cause weak storms. We
show that these geoeffective events (ICMEs or MCs) trigger an increased and
combined auroral kilometric radiation (AKR) and non-thermal continuum (NTC)
wave activity in the magnetosphere, an enhanced convection in the ionosphere,
and a stronger response in the thermosphere. However, this trend does not
appear clearly in the coupling functions, which exhibit relatively weak
correlations between the solar-wind energy input and the amplitude of various
geomagnetic indices, whereas the role of the southward component of the
solar-wind magnetic field is confirmed. Some saturation appears for Dst values
<−100 nT on the integrated values of the polar and auroral indices.
AB - Taking the 32 storm sudden commencements (SSCs)
listed by the International Service of Geomagnetic Indices (ISGI) of the
Observatory de l’Ebre during 2002 (solar activity maximum in Cycle 23) as a
starting point, we performed a multi-criterion analysis based on observations
(propagation time, velocity comparisons, sense of the magnetic field rotation,
radio waves) to associate them with solar sources, identified their effects in
the interplanetary medium, and looked at the response of the terrestrial
ionized and neutral environment. We find that 28 SSCs can be related to 44
coronal mass ejections (CMEs), 15 with a unique CME and 13 with a series of
multiple CMEs, among which 19 (68%) involved halo CMEs. Twelve of the 19
fastest CMEs with speeds greater than 1000 km s−1 are halo CMEs. For the 44
CMEs, including 21 halo CMEs, the corresponding X-ray flare classes are: 4
X-class, 19 M-class, and 21 C-class flares. The probability for an SSC to occur
is 75% if the CME is a halo CME. Among the 500, or even more, front-side,
non-halo CMEs recorded in 2002, only 23 could be the source of an SSC, i.e. 5%.
The complex interactions between two (or more) CMEs and the modification of
their trajectories have been examined using joint white-light and
multiple-wavelength radio observations. The detection of long-lasting type IV
bursts observed at metric–hectometric wavelengths is a very useful criterion
for the CME–SSC association. The events associated with the most depressed Dst
values are also associated with type IV radio bursts. The four SSCs associated
with a single shock at L1 correspond to four radio events exhibiting
characteristics different from type IV radio bursts. The solar-wind structures
at L1 after the 32 SSCs are 12 magnetic clouds (MCs), 6 interplanetary coronal
mass ejections (ICMEs) without an MC structure, 4 miscellaneous structures,
which cannot unambiguously be classified as ICMEs, 5 corotating or stream
interaction regions (CIRs/SIRs), one CIR caused two SSCs, and 4 shock events;
note that one CIR caused two SSCs. The 11 MCs listed in 3 or more MC catalogs
covering the year 2002 are associated with SSCs. For the three most intense
geomagnetic storms (based on Dst minima) related to MCs, we note two sudden
increases of the Dst, at the arrival of the sheath and the arrival of the MC
itself. In terms of geoeffectiveness, the relation between the CME speed and
the magnetic-storm intensity, as characterized using the Dst magnetic index, is
very complex, but generally CMEs with velocities at the Sun larger than 1000
km s−1 have larger probabilities to trigger moderate or intense storms. The
most geoeffective events are MCs, since 92% of them trigger moderate or intense
storms, followed by ICMEs (33%). At best, CIRs/SIRs only cause weak storms. We
show that these geoeffective events (ICMEs or MCs) trigger an increased and
combined auroral kilometric radiation (AKR) and non-thermal continuum (NTC)
wave activity in the magnetosphere, an enhanced convection in the ionosphere,
and a stronger response in the thermosphere. However, this trend does not
appear clearly in the coupling functions, which exhibit relatively weak
correlations between the solar-wind energy input and the amplitude of various
geomagnetic indices, whereas the role of the southward component of the
solar-wind magnetic field is confirmed. Some saturation appears for Dst values
<−100 nT on the integrated values of the polar and auroral indices.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064012823&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1007/s11207-019-1426-6
DO - 10.1007/s11207-019-1426-6
M3 - Comment/debate
AN - SCOPUS:85064012823
SN - 0038-0938
VL - 294
JO - Solar Physics
JF - Solar Physics
IS - 4
M1 - 38
ER -