Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Can Enlightenment Principles Improve Arts Council England Strategy for National Portfolio Orchestras?

  • Eleanor Docx

    Abstract

    In 2019, I became the Communications Director of an orchestra. Immersed in the role, I dedicated myself to selling tickets, attracting press, and embodying Arts Council England’s (ACE) principles. Only after resigning, I realised how this approach compromised my values and degraded both the music and musicians. By adhering to ACE’s Strategy, I championed much of what I now recognise as damaging to the orchestral sector. This thesis attempts to atone for my Neoliberal shill-ery through an ethnographic and philosophically informed critique of ACE.

    ACE is the primary income source for most orchestras in the National Portfolio (ONPs) and as such, has the power to dictate industry strategy. Yet, with this power comes the responsibility to protect the best interest of the workers, audience and music. In the 1940s, the Arts Council strived to do that by promoting cultural enjoyment and shielding artists from market pressures. However, document analysis, supported by industry field notes, highlights a shift from its original Utilitarian philosophy to Political Neoliberalism. This shift prioritises market-driven practices and wealth consolidation, which I argue undermines ONPs’ capacity to serve public wellbeing, causing distress for workers and harming ACE’s sustainability. Urgent reform is necessary.

    I argue that, despite operating within a Neoliberal framework, ACE holds unique potential to drive systemic change. By revisiting Utilitarianism, informed by the Enlightenment Principles ACE could influence policy upstream at the government level and downstream among ONPs. Grounded in a decade of orchestral experience, this thesis bridges theoretical critique and practical insight. By addressing gaps in existing evaluations of ACE’s strategy, it offers a fresh perspective, advocating for reforms that realign orchestras with public value.
    Date of Award26 Jun 2025
    Original languageEnglish
    Awarding Institution
    • Northumbria University
    SupervisorMartyn Hudson (Supervisor) & David Smith (Supervisor)

    Keywords

    • Neoliberalism
    • Rethinking Cultural Policy
    • ACE
    • Orchestral Management and Administration
    • Neoliberal Order

    Cite this

    '