Abstract
Physical activity (PA) is promoted to enhance children’s cognitive and academic outcomes, yet research on acute PA bouts shows inconsistent results, limited ecological validity, and little qualitative insight. Underpinned by Empowerment Theory, Critical Realism, and Pragmatism, this mixed-methods Thesis comprises four studies exploring the cognitive and academic impacts of acute PA and foregrounding children’s and teachers’ voices.Study 1: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effects of acute PA bouts on children’s executive function (EF) and academic achievement (AA) identified no significant effects but revealed methodological inconsistencies and highlighted the need for context-specific research, insights that shaped subsequent studies.
Studies 2 and 3: Focus groups with children and teachers respectively, analysed through Reflexive Thematic Analysis, yielded themes of Enjoyment, Exercise ‘Wind-Down’ Period (the need to calm down before learning), Perceived Benefits (cognitive and academic improvements), and Adaptability/Flexibility (tailoring to unique contexts), illustrating the realworld complexities that surround the integration of PA across the school day.
Study 4: Guided by the previous studies, a cluster-randomised crossover trial tested a PA break, designed with input from children and teachers, against usual practice. While EF and class behaviour did not differ, the PA break elicited higher affect, arousal, exertion, and enjoyment, suggesting that participant-informed approaches may match established practices in cognitive and behavioural outcomes while enhancing engagement.
Overall, this Thesis synthesises and critically appraises the acute PA-cognition/AA literature, provides qualitative accounts of school-based PA experiences, and evaluates an ecologically valid PA break. Taken together, the findings demonstrate that while pupils and teachers value adaptability and enjoyment, a PA break developed with their insight enhanced enjoyment without compromising cognitive or behavioural outcomes. This Thesis offers practical guidance for invested groups (e.g. educators, policymakers) seeking to embed meaningful and enjoyable PA opportunities across the school day to improve children’s cognitive and academic capabilities, and their general wellbeing.
| Date of Award | 28 May 2026 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Supervisor | Nicola McCullogh (Supervisor), Gavin Tempest (Supervisor) & Florentina Hettinga (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- Preadolescent Children
- Schools
- Education
- Behaviour
- Executive Function
Cite this
- Standard